Fresh-delivery dog food brands typically charge AUD $12-18 per day for a medium dog. The same nutrition, home-cooked from supermarket ingredients with an AAFCO-aligned premix, costs around $5-9 a day all-in (premix included). Here's the breakdown of what you're paying for in subscriptions, and how the maths shifts when you cook yourself.
I'm Teddy. My human looked at the fresh-delivery dog food market when she started taking my diet seriously. The food is good. The science is real — these are properly formulated, complete-and-balanced meals delivered to your door. The problem is the price.
For a 10kg dog, fresh-delivery dog food in Australia runs about $400 to $550 a month, depending on the brand and the plan. Multiply by 12 years of a dog's life and you're at roughly $60,000. Per dog. That's not a complaint about quality — it's a complaint about needing to spend $60,000 to feed your dog real food.
This guide is the alternative version: same nutrition, fraction of the cost, slightly more effort.
What you're paying for in fresh-delivery dog food
The subscription brands aren't wrong to charge what they charge. Roughly, your monthly fee covers:
- Ingredients — about 25-30% of your total bill. The food itself.
- Cold-chain logistics — refrigerated trucking, insulated packaging, dry ice. Around 20-30% of the bill. Fresh dog food has to stay fresh during delivery.
- Marketing and customer acquisition — pet food is one of the most expensive marketing categories in Australia. Subscription brands typically spend $80-150 to acquire each customer. That cost is in your monthly price.
- Convenience and trust premium — you're paying for "I don't have to think about it." That's a real value proposition. It just isn't cheap.
- Margin — venture-backed brands need to grow, which means margins higher than what a traditional pet food company would charge.
None of these are wrong. They're how a subscription business operates. The question is whether you, for your dog, want to pay for all of them.
What the same nutrition costs to cook yourself
For a 10kg adult dog eating around 560 kcal/day, here's what one of our 5 recipes costs from Coles or Woolworths, calculated at recent prices:
- Chicken thigh (skin off): roughly $3.85/day (~350 g raw at $11/kg)
- Butternut, carrot, cauliflower & spinach: roughly $0.55/day
- Olive oil and iodised salt: roughly $0.05/day
- The Premix: roughly $0.90/day (7.5 g)
- Energy + your time: roughly $0.20/day if you batch-cook
That's about $5.55 per day, or roughly $170 a month — for the same dog that costs $400-550 a month on a fresh-delivery subscription.
The savings compound. Over 12 years for one dog, you're looking at roughly $43,000 in difference. That's a year of mortgage payments. It's a real number.
What you're trading off
Honest version: this isn't free. You're giving up four real things to get those savings.
Convenience. Someone has to cook the food. For a single dog with batch cooking, this is about 90 minutes once a week. For multiple dogs or larger dogs, scale up. If your weekly calendar doesn't have 90 minutes free, a subscription brand might be the right call for you.
Variety automation. Subscription brands automatically rotate proteins to keep variety in your dog's diet. If you cook yourself, you have to remember to switch recipes every few weeks.
Cold-chain handling. Their packaging is engineered to keep food at the right temperature from their facility to your fridge. When you cook, you have to portion and freeze it yourself.
The peace-of-mind premium. If you've never cooked for a dog before, the first few weeks feel uncertain. Am I doing this right? Is the calcium balanced? Did I miss something? This is real anxiety. A subscription removes it. A well-built recipe + premix system also removes it, but the trust has to be built.
What you're getting back
Cost savings are the obvious one. But there are three more you might not have thought about:
Full ingredient visibility. You picked the chicken thigh. You know what brand. You washed the broccoli. There's no batch tracking issue, no quality control surprise, no "we changed our supplier last month" — because the supplier is you.
Allergy and sensitivity control. If your dog reacts to chicken, you can switch to kangaroo this week and back if you want. Subscriptions limit your protein rotation to what they offer.
The cooking ritual. Sounds soft, but most home-cooking dog owners say the Sunday cooking session becomes a real part of the week. The dog watches you cook. The kitchen smells like food the dog can eat. The relationship changes.
The hybrid path
Worth noting: this isn't all-or-nothing. Some people use a subscription for weekdays and cook fresh on weekends. Some cook for 5 nights and use kibble as a fallback. Some cook entirely.
Our recipes and Premix are designed to plug into whichever model works for you. The Premix doses by meal size, not by lifestyle commitment. If you only cook half your dog's meals, that's still better than zero.
What "complete and balanced" looks like at $4 a day
To be clear about quality: home-cooked + premix isn't a budget compromise. Done right, it's nutritionally equivalent to (and in some cases better than) fresh-delivery food.
The premix is the key. Without it, home-cooked dog food has the deficiency problems described in our guide on making homemade dog food complete. With it — and a recipe designed around AAFCO standards — the nutrition profile is identical to commercial complete-and-balanced food. The difference is just where the labour and margin go.
Our guide on dog multivitamins in Australia covers how to evaluate a premix product properly.
Common questions
Is home-cooked actually better for my dog?
Honest answer: not necessarily, if "better" means measurable health outcomes. A properly formulated commercial diet — including the good fresh-delivery brands — is genuinely complete and balanced. What home-cooked gives you is control, transparency, ingredient choice, and significantly lower cost. Not magic.
How much time does this actually take?
For one medium dog with batch cooking: about 90 minutes on Sunday, plus a couple of minutes per meal to portion. For two dogs or larger dogs: scale up the cooking time, but portioning stays fast.
What about my dog's allergies?
Our 5 recipes cover the main protein sources (chicken, beef, kangaroo, lamb, turkey). If your dog reacts to one, switch to another. With a subscription brand you're limited to their protein list; with home cooking you choose.
Can I really skip the calcium and calorie calculations?
Yes — that's the point of the Premix and the recipes together. The calculator works out portion sizes for you, the recipes have the ratios already balanced, and the Premix dose scales with the meal. The maths is done; you just cook.
See what your dog's plan would cost
Our calculator estimates the daily cost of feeding your dog home-cooked, complete and balanced food — and shows you which of our 5 recipes suits them best.
Build a plan